4 Comments
User's avatar
Laurenz Guenther's avatar

Thanks, great post! I agree.

One thing that came to my mind: the US had a similar immigration crisis in the early 20th century, which culminated in the Immigration Act of 1924. It may be useful to compare this past sequence of events to what is happening now.

Luke Eure's avatar

Thank you! And it definitely seems worth exploring the parallels in more detail

Yonah Borns-Weil's avatar

Nothing in this post is wrong, but as someone who is friends with many (legal) immigrants and was in a relationship with one for a long time, I feel like it elides that there is _some_ tradeoff between recruitment and enforcement.

What I have repeatedly heard during both Trump administrations is the constant low-level fear that immigrants have, that they may have messed up crossing a single t or forgotten to check some box, or even that they just get misidentified or mistaken, and they suddenly fall in the unforgiving “illegal” pile with no recourse. Some say this gave them active second thoughts about staying, and I wouldn’t be surprised if it changed people’s behavior at the margin.

A very harsh bouncer does make the job of a recruiter (or to keep the analogy the same, a promoter) more difficult, even if voters want both and both have a role to play.

Luke Eure's avatar

Yeah there is for sure some inherent tension here, and some amount of tradeoff

Two things that make me not quite as worried about the tension though:

1. Much of this is a function of the immigration system being unnecessarily complicated, rather than a function of enforcement per se. It’s easier to both bounce and promote when immigration law is more legible

2. There is also an attitude and vibes question. The Trump admin, despite Trump’s occasional comments otherwise, has chosen the overall vibe of “hostile to immigrants”. This doesn’t necessarily have to be the case. They would be more popular (a would have Biden) if they took an effective stance against illegal immigration while not actively trying to scare all immigrants